Rains Lucia Stern St. Phalle & Silver

California's premier full-service law firm with an emphasis on the representation of peace officers in disciplinary, criminal, labor, workers' compensation, personal injury and other civil matters.

  • About Us
  • Practice Areas
    • Labor Representation
    • Civil Litigation
    • Personal Injury
      • Example of Case Results
    • Workers’ Compensation
    • Maritime Law
    • Estate Planning
    • DOE Security Clearance Hearings
    • Peace Officers
    • Firefighters
    • EMS Agency Investigations
    • Criminal Defense
    • CalPERS Appeals
  • Our Team
  • Classes
  • Media
    • Bulletins
    • RLS in the News
  • Resources
    • Links
    • Resources
    • Newsletters
  • Clients
  • Career Opportunities
  • Contact Us
  • Disclaimer

After Oakland Fire, Long Legal Battle Looms With Uncertain Prospects

December 10, 2016 by Hien Nguyen

From: The Recorder
By Ben Hancock 12/6/16

SAN FRANCISCO — As Oakland prosecutors conduct a criminal probe into the tragic warehouse fire that killed at least 36 people last Friday, lawyers are predicting a long stretch of civil legal battles ahead for the bereaved families and say that securing damages will be difficult.

There are a number of parties that could share civil liability over the blaze, according to attorneys specializing in accidents, dangerous premises and landlord-tenant law. But whether those accountable can pay any amount—let alone damages that would deliver some semblance of justice—is a question mark at this point.

Among the primary targets of any civil litigation after the blaze are the warehouse owner, identified by local media as Chor Ng, and a man who reportedly collected rent from other tenants at what was dubbed the “Ghost Ship,” Derick Ion Almena.

There’s also the possibility that product liability suits could be filed if authorities find that some sort of appliance or electrical device was responsible for igniting the blaze, attorneys said. Investigators on Wednesday were looking at a refrigerator at the back of the warehouse as being the potential source of the fire, according to press reports.

Local authorities charged with building inspections, meanwhile, are unlikely to be successfully sued, attorneys said, because state law grants these officials wide immunity.

“The government is pretty good at exempting itself from responsibility,” said Christopher Dolan, a personal injury lawyer at the Dolan Law Firm in San Francisco, who said he had already been contacted by victims’ families about possible lawsuits. “I think that’s a total tragedy because it creates what we’ll call a moral hazard of people looking the other way.”

The East Bay Times and other media outlets on Tuesday reported on what they characterized as a series of missed opportunities for local authorities to catch the dangers that were present at the warehouse, which was consumed in flames last Friday night during an electronic music event.

For Ng and Almena, the extent of their liability­­—and whether they could be subjected to punitive damages—will depend upon the degree to which they were aware that there were hazards and failed to correct them. But Ng could also be on the hook simply for allowing the building to be occupied when the building was not approved for residential use, lawyers said.

“I’m going to speculate that those owners had every reason to believe that people were living in there, and that they were on notice, literally or constructively, of the dangerous, nonconforming construction,” said Steven Adair MacDonald, who practices landlord-tenant law in San Francisco.

Also potentially liable are the individuals or companies who did construction or electrical work inside the warehouse, and the promoters of the music event that was getting underway when the fire broke out, said Christopher Viadro, name partner at Butler Viadro in Oakland.

“If you’re inviting a large number of people to an area where there’s not going to be an appropriate amount of access … 99.99 percent of the time this wouldn’t turn into a death trap, but in the less the 1 percent [chance], you have to contemplate that,” Viadro said of event promoters. The building was not equipped with sprinklers and only had two exits, one of which was blocked, according to news reports.

Eustace de Saint Phalle, an attorney at Rains Lucia Stern who is involved in litigation around the collapse of an apartment balcony in Berkeley in 2015, which killed six, said he expects the litigation after the Oakland fire to follow a similar track—albeit on a larger scale.

District Attorney Nancy O’Malley—whose jurisdiction includes Berkeley and Oakland—declined to bring criminal charges in that case. But families of the victims and survivors of the collapse filed 13 lawsuits against the building’s owner and manager, in addition to the construction firm that built the balcony.

If the DA’s office files criminal charges in the Oakland fire case, it’s likely that any civil action will be stayed pending trial or settlement. A criminal conviction or guilty plea could go a long way toward establishing the liability of the defendants in a civil case, attorneys noted.

But whether those defendants would be able to pay is another matter. MacDonald said that in his reckoning, Almena—to the extent he may be liable—would be “judgment proof.” “People like that, they don’t have assets. Why would they be living in a warehouse?” he said.

The owner of the warehouse may be in a better position to pay any damages, MacDonald added. They would typically carry several million dollars in liability insurance, and may have personal assets as well. But attorneys noted that with at least 36 families affected, that’s not a lot to go around.

William Friedrich, a defense litigator at Farella Braun + Martel, said that while he anticipates civil suits, not everyone who may share responsibility will be roped in. “I hate to boil this down to economics,” said Friedrich, “but experienced plaintiffs lawyers are going to want to find responsible parties that have money.”

Attorneys said that in addition to collection of damages, apportioning responsibility for the blaze is likely to be a major fight in any ensuing civil litigation. Defendants will point fingers at who else shares blame, while lawyers of the families will have to argue who contributed the most to the ultimate harm.

“Somebody clearly was at fault. I think that’s a given,” said Viadro. “These things don’t happen without somebody making a mistake.”

Filed Under: RLS In The News Tagged With: eustace-de-saint-phalle

Consultation Form

Offices across California to serve you.
Contact us now to schedule a consultation.
Contact form not loading? Click here!
Rains Lucia Stern St. Phalle & Silver, PC publishes this website as a service to our clients and other friends for informational purposes only. It is not intended to be used as a substitute for specific legal advice or opinions, and the transmission of information through this website is not intended to create an attorney-client relationship between sender and receiver. Internet subscribers and online readers should not act upon this information without seeking professional counsel.

© 2023 Rains Lucia Stern St. Phalle & Silver, PC. All Rights Reserved. | Disclaimer

We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. By clicking “Accept”, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies.
Do not sell my personal information.
Cookie settingsACCEPTREJECT
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Non-necessary
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
SAVE & ACCEPT
  • Contact Us

  • News Alerts

Official logo for Rains Lucia Stern St. Phalle & Silver
Rains Lucia Stern St. Phalle & Silver Logo
  • About Us
  • Practice Areas
    ▼
    • Labor Representation
    • Civil Litigation
    • Personal Injury
      ▼
      • Example of Case Results
    • Workers’ Compensation
    • Maritime Law
    • Estate Planning
    • DOE Security Clearance Hearings
    • Peace Officers
    • Firefighters
    • EMS Agency Investigations
    • Criminal Defense
    • CalPERS Appeals
  • Our Team
  • Classes
  • Media
    ▼
    • Bulletins
    • RLS in the News
  • Resources
    ▼
    • Links
    • Resources
    • Newsletters
  • Clients
  • Career Opportunities
  • Contact Us
  • Disclaimer
Hotline phone numbers. Northern California: 925-609-1699. Southern California: 310-393-1486.